Global Campaign for Microbicides

Home

Home » Trial Ethics » Activities & Workshops » Consultation ethical-legal concerns Sept 07

Consultation ethical-legal concerns Sept 07

Consultation on ethical-legal concerns in HIV vaccine and microbicide trial

To access the full report of this two day consultation prepared by the the HIV AIDS Vaccines Ethics Group & the Global Campaign for Microbicides click here (360KB).

Day 1 - 5 September 2007
0800 Registration - participants list - Agenda
0900 Welcome Lori Heise, GCM
0910 Hoped for outcomes Ann Strode, HAVEG

Session I Checking on adolescents in HIV vaccine and microbicide trials:

Where are we and why are we still here?

Objectives: Review the status of adolescent involvement in HIV vaccine and microbicide trials. Where have we been? Where are we now? Where are we going? What are the key problems and impasses that keep us from moving forward?

09:15 Adolescents in microbicide trials Craig Wilson, ATN
09:40 Adolescents in HIV vaccine trials Linda-Gail Bekker, DTHC
10:05 Questions and discussion
10:30 Tea

Session II Reviewing the ethical-legal problems in adolescent HIV vaccine and microbicide trials: What do we know? What new issues are coming up?

Objectives: Review the ethical-legal challenges, concerns and impasses. What issues have already been identified in the literature? What emerging issues are there?

11:00 Adolescents in trials: An ethical-legal analysis Quarraisha Abdool Karim, CAPRISA, HPTN
11:30 An advocacy perspective Kola Oyedeji NHVMAG
11:45 Overview of published literature - Essack, Slack & Strode (2207) Towards… Catherine Slack, HAVEG
12:15 Discussion
13:00 Lunch

Session III Refining the problems: A problem analysis

Objectives: Develop a more refined view of the problems in
i Community - ii Science - iii Ethical - iv Legal / Regulatory domains. (a) What are the issues? (b) What are the priorities? (c) What’s unique to HIV vaccine trials versus Microbicide trials (d) What is unique to “South” or North” settings?

14:00

Group-work instructions

Vernon Solomon, HAVEG
14:15 Group-work: Rotational brainstorming
16:30 Closing instructions
18:00 Cocktails and buffet dinner
Day 2 - 6 September 2007

Session IV Feedback from groups and towards consensus on priorities

Objectives: Discuss priorities identified by each group. Build consensus on most critical concerns

09:00 Feedback from groups
10:00 Facilitated discussion
10:30 Tea

Session V Positioning microbidices and HIV vaccines

Objectives: To identify where the fields are at in terms of history, science and political considerations

11:00 Input from Lori
11:10 Input from Craig
11:20 Facilitated discussion
12:00

Groupwork - 2 large groups:
HIV Vaccine Trials and Microbicides Trials considering most impactful next steps to advance the optimal involvement of adolescents

13:00 Lunch
14:00 Feedback from both groups
14:30 Activity mapping
15:00

Close

Cathy and Lori